• 1300 118 818/+61731033300
  • info@wfyaulawyers.com


Property Law Understand Testamentary Trusts and the differences between Discretionary Trusts

Understand Testamentary Trusts and the differences between Discretionary Trusts

A testamentary trust is a legal entity established through a will, which becomes operative only after the death of the testator. Unlike inter vivos (living) trusts that take effect immediately, testamentary trusts are enacted upon the execution of the testator’s will. In essence, a testamentary trust delineates the management and distribution of assets after the testator’s demise, serving as a mechanism to safeguard beneficiaries’ interests and ensure the efficient transfer of wealth. These trusts commonly come into play in scenarios where the testator seeks to provide ongoing financial support or protection for beneficiaries, such as minors, individuals with special needs, or spendthrift heirs.

One of the primary distinctions between testamentary trusts and discretionary trusts lies in their timing of activation. Testamentary trusts are activated posthumously, triggered by the terms of the will, while discretionary trusts are established during the settlor’s lifetime. Discretionary trusts grant the trustee broad discretion in distributing assets among beneficiaries, enabling flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances and needs. Conversely, testamentary trusts are governed by the specific instructions outlined in the will, leaving less room for trustee discretion.

Furthermore, the nature of beneficiaries differs between testamentary trusts and discretionary trusts. In testamentary trusts, beneficiaries are typically predetermined in the will, with specific individuals or entities designated to receive trust assets. Conversely, discretionary trusts often involve a class of potential beneficiaries, allowing the trustee discretion to select recipients based on criteria outlined in the trust deed. This key distinction influences the level of control exerted by the settlor over asset distribution and the trustee’s decision-making authority.

Another fundamental difference lies in the purpose and function of these trusts. Testamentary trusts primarily serve as vehicles for estate planning and asset protection, ensuring the orderly transfer of wealth and providing for the financial well-being of beneficiaries over the long term. In contrast, discretionary trusts are commonly utilized for various purposes, including tax planning, asset protection, and charitable giving, offering greater flexibility in managing assets and optimizing tax efficiencies.

Additionally, the legal framework governing testamentary trusts and discretionary trusts varies. Testamentary trusts are subject to probate proceedings and the jurisdictional regulations governing wills and estates, whereas discretionary trusts operate within the framework of trust law and are governed by the terms outlined in the trust deed. This distinction influences factors such as administration costs, privacy, and the level of court oversight involved in trust management.

In conclusion, testamentary trusts and discretionary trusts represent distinct yet valuable tools in the realm of estate planning and asset management. While testamentary trusts are activated posthumously and adhere strictly to the terms of the will, discretionary trusts offer flexibility and discretion in asset distribution during the settlor’s lifetime. Understanding the differences between these trusts is crucial for individuals seeking to structure their estates effectively and provide for the financial security of their loved ones. By leveraging the unique features of testamentary trusts and discretionary trusts, individuals can tailor their estate plans to meet their specific objectives and ensure the preservation and transfer of wealth in accordance with their wishes.

It is a must to seek professional tax advice from a qualified tax adviser familiar with Australian tax law to ensure compliance and optimize tax efficiency when dealing with testamentary trust.